I lost length due to pumping

Why is that is it due to girth gains ?

Too many factors to consider, provide more information.

If I had to guess based on your answer, yes because of girth, leads me to believe your pump is too big for you.

Pumping has made me gain length. I’m a solid 5inch erect girth. Been using a 1.75” cylinder. I pack the tube for the first 1.5 - 2 inches. Been using it since the first day of March 2020. Been getting 1/8thinch length gains ~ every month

I was thinking PE had progressions and regressions naturally but yes I have a

2.5 diameter cylinder and thought length gains were still possible

Narrow cylinders give me blisters

Wow I might need to get a smaller cylinder I have a 2.5 diameter

I was told length gains were still possible though with the cylinder I have

When I enter the tube I’m a half inch shorter than my bpel

After my session I’m usually ABOVE my bpel

The ONLY way a penis will be reduced in length and/or girth is due to over training.

Take 2 complete off days of any kind of PE training and remeasure

I think it might be useful to clarify if you lost length to your non-pumped erect size or just to either post pump or in tube size.

I’ve occasionally noticed the penis becoming a little shorter in the tube and post pump when using a large diameter cylinder (relative to my girth), but I’ve never noticed a shortening of erect length outside of the normal variation of my erect length the next day.

I’m not 100% tube packing causes faster gains to length yet, it might just be limiting girth gains.

What amount of vacuum pressure are you using? Higher vacuum pressures in themselves seem to be able to cause at least a temporary reduction in length.

It could also be that your erection strength is just not strong enough for full length expansion right now, which can happen from pumping but, in my experience, resolves on its own with a break.

Pumping is a more girth focused exercise and not the best way to gain length.

If you use a big cylinder instead of a narrow one, you will increase the overall volume, but not so much length. Especially in the first weeks or months your length can be compromised.

Length in the pump is therefore not a good indicator for a good session.
Since pumping is a marathon it can take some time until the length increases in a big cylinder.
More length will happen when you max out your potential girth after some time.

As long as you are bigger outside the tube after a session, all is good.
Since your bpel is longer than before the session there are no concerns right now as the results are expected.

To counteract these “problems” I combined 2 cylinders in my sessions to get the best of both worlds so to say.

i.e. starting out with the large cylinder to get a faster max expansion in all directions (volume) and then using a narrow cylinder to focus on expanding vertically or packing it.

Pumping is a bit tricky. You need to take a break of at least 14 days to cancel out any temp gains to see the real results.
For most guys this means loosing a lot of gains. In my case I gained 1,5 cm length after a couple of months when I started out and lost about 1 cm in temp gains after a 14 days break. This can be very discouraging.

I did not see you mentioning vacuum level, so I suppose you do not have a gauge and determine by feel and length in the cylinder. Maybe you are using too much high pressure and this results in bad EQ, not actual length lose.

I’ll just say I gained all of my length from pumping. It’s not just for girth.

WoW! Really? That s awesome!
Can you please tell me how many minutes per session and how many days/week?

I worked up to three hours split up into one hour sessions. Constant heat was a big part of the increase. After a hour I would edge for 15 minutes or so and then resume. At the mid point I wanted to exceed my BPEL. The second half of the routine help solidify the routine.

It’s not to be used starting out. It took time and patience to be able to pump that long without blisters.

Thank you for the reply.

I saw some pics of you in your thread the other day and I noticed the curve .

Did all these gains u had made the curve any better? did it worsen? did it stay the same?

I’d say it’s a bit straighter.