9 too much

I think, at least from what I have seen, that is accurate. Maybe a little conservative on the girth side as well

OK, I understand now that you created that table to demonstrate what Phyriel’s apparent suggestion of a 3 - 4” overestimation factor, would result in over a wide range of sizes, particularly relatively smaller ones.

I think it would be more accurate to say that womens’ overestimation of penis size is probably proportional to length, rather than a specific amount across all size ranges as Phyriel’s post might seem to suggest - though perhaps that wasn’t really what he intended. If the overstimation factor were, say, around 30%, then a genuinely oversized penis of 7 - 8” length might get reported as 3” longer or 10” - 11”, which is consistent with some of the reports I’ve seen of womens’ overestimations, particularly statements by women that they have slept with more 10” partners than is statistically plausible for such a genuinely rare length; and at a more average length of 5.5 - 6” the overestimation would be more like 2”, which also seems consistent with women talking about 8” penises being common.

It’s also not implausible that at least a few women - who probably tend to look at a penis more from the underside, where its starting point is less clearly delineated - may genuinely believe that a penis is measured by the entire length of the corpora cavernosa down to near the anus, which is actually technically correct from the point of view of anatomy, and so would add about the amount suggest by Phyriel to any penis. Also, apparently some people at least think that measuring from the side, which results in larger numbers, is actually correct.

This does remind me that our top-down, BP/NBP oriented approach to penis size, is very male- and PE- centric, and that women may indeed have a genuinely different perspective on penis size and measuring.

FF

Almost as bad as guys that think porn stars have 12 inch cocks. It ain’t just women.

I was just making fun about it, and even on bang bros sites when they measure the guys it’s like 1” or 2” round up, it’s photographic evidence.

Yeah, like women just relying on their overall senses. kdoc’s study indicates 1” L x .5” G to be a common result, not 2, 3 , 4 inches. It’s reasonable. In your posts your usual goal is to downplay how many big guys exist and how much size counts but I think you’re going too wild with the numbers and in your attempt to bring reality to the forum you are overshooting the mark. Nevertheless I like to give credit where I believe credit is due and in kdoc’s study thread I noted that his 5.5 girth result supports what FF has been saying for quite some time.

It seems some girls just tell other girls how big a guy is by using their hands to demonstrate. Then they over estimate when they guess how many inches that is. For example, my girlfriend didn’t know my size, she just told her friends she thought I was huge. When they asked how big, she held out her hands and said, “When I jack him off, I can get two hands around it and still have some room to move up and down.”

Her friends looked at her hands in awe and were like, “Whoa! He must be like 10 inches long!”

They all looked at each other and agreed. So now she and all her friends think I have a 10 inch cock. I’m not going to correct them ;)

Thus the legend begins. B-)

That’s exactly what I am talking about!