In fact I’ve had a similar conversation with women, and many of them responded with disgust and distaste at the thought of a penis the size of someone like Mandingo (9x5.75?).
Without wishing to rehash old arguments, I’m pretty sure Mandingo is considerably bigger than this. I started with very nearly that girth before I even began PE, and I peaked at 9” BP dead on when I stopped PEing regularly a few years ago. Titleist is certainly bigger than me and, with all due respect, I would estimate Mandingo is bigger still.
But even then, I doubt he’s quite 7” girth at mid-shaft.