What penis length is too long?

I was thinking about this for a while. First, I thought about ball size and I was looking through some articles and these balls are definitely way too big (warning as pictures can be disturbing):

http://onlineli brary.wiley.com … 008.07559.x/pdf

Just wondering what length do you think looks too long? So it starts to look like the ball sizes above, where it starts to look almost abnormal (if that’s even possible). My cut-off is ~10" NBPEL. I actually would not want anything more than this and would prefer to be smaller. So, for example, is someone told me you can have an ~11" penis (and stuck with it) versus and 8" one, I’d rather have 8" one. Between 8-10", though it would be a far more difficult decision.

I know you’re just thinking of ball size, but you’ve got to think about height too.

-If you’re 7’ tall, a 10” penis still might not look that big.
-If you’re 5’ even, 8” might look ridiculous.

I’m 5’10”, let’s assume I can be any length I want, I’m sure there’s a point where things will start to look freakish. What is that point? I don’t know. I guess I have the same question as you but I also worry about the height aspect in addition to ball size.

Okay. Man… I wont be able to get an erection for the rest of the night thanks to that pdf. Just a double disturbance warning.

At 5’ 7” I would probably start to look freakish with an 8.5”. I think it also depends on how far down your leg it goes. Some people have longer legs and others have longer torsos.

I’m 5’4” and I’m just under 8” BPEL (hope to be there by the end of the year) with very little fat pad <1/4”. I sure hope I look ridiculous! That’s what I’m shooting for. ;-)

You’re very super 100% right about that.. I cringed at most of them and as if I was watching a horror film I kept saying, “no, no, no, no”.
Those are some very disturbing pictures.

Whatever length her ex was.

a) If you’re speaking of aesthetics then this is exclusively to the taste of the beholder and hence fairly meaningless to try to determine as a general rule. People will have different cut-offs. Also, flaccid to erect ratios, length to girth ratio and all that come into play, not just a single number.

b) If you’re speaking of (sexual) functionality then this is a compromise of the preference of all parties involved and hence fairly meaningless to try to determine as a general rule, as some like it bigger than others.

c) If you’re speaking of day-to-day functionality then this is down the the individual and hence fairly meaningless to try to determine as a general rule, as some guys won’t mind massive swinging salami whereas others will find it a burden to cope with during simple tasks like walking.

Personally, in those three categories, I:

a) think that on my fairly large body size, my fairly long penis looks average and would prefer it to be a bit longer, mostly in the flaccid state but also somewhat in the erect. But I’m more interested in girth, still.

b) find that some of my length is wasted anyways as at least 2-3 inches hang out of my lady during deepest penetration. When she’s pretty fucked up and stretchable, I can go perhaps an inch or more further in with no pain but feel a definite wall and resistance to going further (plus some pain with too much pressure). I would prefer to be balls deep, so to me I’m actually past the “too long” point in this category (at least specifically for her). It’s something of an ego-boost for me (and her, in fact) though, so it’s a strange dichotomy there.

c) sometimes catch people taking a glimpse at my package which doesn’t really bother me. It can be a little distracting at times. I have never really found any difficulty in day to day activity due to the length of my penis. For example, it has never got caught in a lawn mower or meat grinder.

Quote of the week :)

I read somewhere that a visible penis length (NBPEL) that is 10% of body height is most esthetically pleasing and I think for my part that is pretty accurate.

So a guy who is 5’ 10” high and has a NBPEL of 7” will look big, but not disproportionate.

Ok. I didn’t need the pictures.

I generally agree that visually an abnormally large penis would depend on the body size of the man. For an average build man at 5’ 10” a 8-9” penis would start to be visually monstrous.

The real issue is what secjay started writing about. When the woman/women you are with cannot handle your size, it starts to become painful, and you don’t get sex as often because of it. That is when it is really too big in my book.

Big is great, but for me if you can use it what’s the point?

Take care and happy gains,

I’m shooting for 7.5”x5.75” because I think it’s ideal for girls and it will also look pretty big on my height and weight. I think I wouldn’t ever want anything bigger than 8”x6”.

Anything over 8 inches is to long but it doesn’t stop some of us wanting it.

I warn people and they still look. That’s my height (slightly higher with shoes). My NBPEL of a little longer than 7” looks somewhat shorter than it is because I have slight left curvature, it is quite thick for the length and my arms and legs are relatively long for my height. So I suppose that’s why I want an 8” NBPEL. Having said that I have changed my mind about girth. I don’t want anything thicker. I’m ~6” throughout (even my head).

Anything over 10” for me is starting to look silly (too long). Between 8-10”, it’s a coin toss and the ego in me would probably take the 10”. The practical in me would take the 8”, I think. So I would probably compromise and take the 9” if given the choice, I suppose. But I’m pretty sure that 9” is unattainable but 8” is and that’s my goal. I would also like somewhat lower hanging and somewhat bigger balls, although, I’ve improved since starting PEing.

I’m 6’ 2” and I think a great size for my frame would be 10.5x7.5; everything would seem proportional. Sometimes I think my girth makes my dick look shorter than it really is.

Lol, a forearm.