If jelqing works why doesn't pumping work

Pumping does more work than jelqing drawing more blood forcing more tissue to expand more when using the pump

So?

Pumping does work. It’s just tricky to find a routine that works for YOU.

Are you saying that pumping doesn’t seem to work for you? There are a lot of guys here, myself included, that have definitely achieved gains from pumping.

I think he is referring to statements made about permanent gains obtained via pumping, and how the general consensus is that a pumping only routine does not produce permanent results.

^^ Yea pumping gains arent permanent

Respectfully, I beg to differ. Pumping has provided the largest and most lasting results I’ve ever achieved. Like the other PE disciplines it takes time consistency.

I do not pump, hence I stay clear from threads involving the discipline. I just happened to notice that the answers our new brother was getting are directed to his personal efforts, as opposed to that ongoing debate. Personally, I have no idea what pumping does in the permanent gains department.

Yes, I was correct. (:

I’m really confused why is jelqing the 1st priority out of these penis enlargement tools.

Pumping and extenders is giving more force and time than jelqing does

If not why not do all of them together?

Jelqing is probably milder at least to begin with. I’ve been injured twice but it’s only minor injuries, hanging and pumping can cause severe injuries if they aren’t handled with care. I have no experience with extenders but I’m not sure only stretching itself leads to significant gains.

Pumping does produce perminant gains if done correctly. I made my first quarter inch gain in length from 2 months of pumping. Alot of people say that pumping only causes fluid build up expansion but that’s not the case if you pump with mild pressure. Lets say that you have a 6 inchs bonepressed length and inside the pump your penis’s bonepressed length grows to 7 inches after 15 minutes. The temporary 1 inch increase in length while in the pump was because of raw tissue expansion and stretching of the tunica inside the pump. Fluid build up will normally fill up under the skin and expand girth wise but not length wise. So with Pumping consistancy combined with other forms of PE perminant results can be made.

Well said.

Ding ding ding ding!

He’s the winner of a brand new car!

That’s exactly what I’ve found to be true Saiyan! Why I’m stretched in my tube right now!

Saiyan’s post explains why real pumping works.

To the OP: I think that the reason why people think pumping does not work is because they chase edema, or lymph fluid build up, instead of true in the tube expansion, most visibly increasing the in-cylinder BPEL. They get fooled by the edema and never learn to use a pump correctly.

I actually believe there’s more to it than that, but this is the brief answer.

This isn’t true.

Pumping achieves a pressure difference by two means. One is reduced atmospheric pressure. The other is the force of your own blood pressure pushing blood into the corpora cavernosa (CC). The combination of these two forces are what causes tissue expansion. However, the reduction in atmospheric pressure does not occur only around the CC, but around the whole penis. This allows fluid migration from within the lymph and blood vessels into the tissues, which in effect reduces the expansion possibilities of the CC.

Jelqing is a mechanical force achieved by forcing blood in a partially erect penis against the tissues of the CC, expanding them and stimulating growth to accommodate the high pressures. You can easily generate more force using your hands than you can by relying on blood pressure combined with negative atmospheric pressure. And with the jelq stroke you confine the application of this pressure to the CC only.

That’s why jelqing is the preferred method. That doesn’t mean that pumping can’t be used successfully, it just means that jelqing is better at achieving the goal of tissue expansion.

Excellent post, Saiyan22.