How big is too big?

Pretty sure a lot of porn stars are approximatively your size. They just look bigger due to camera tricks.

Porn stars typically are in the 6.5 to just under 8” range. Anyone larger is in the legend status and several who aren’t are also in that status. Peter North is 8x6, I believe. I think Billy Glyde is 7.2x6” or something to that effect. So…keep that in mind.

Too big - is defined by the North American Phalicological Society as being any dick over 8.165 bpel and 6.265 meg.

I think it really starts to look porn-big around 6.3” NBP. If the guy is short and thin enough.

Maybe it’s given my size, but most guys in porn don’t look that big (some even look sort of small length wise)…only the really huge guys look big, at least to me.

I’m not sure I agree with some of the girth charts on here. My most recent partner never complained once about my girth, or complimented it in fact. On the other hand I’ve had women who would stop me after a few minutes. I’d say about half the girls I’ve been with DON’T like my girth, a few have complimented it/ liked it and others just don’t really care or say anything. I’ve really come to understand that EVERY woman is different in some way

Well I just made them all up from anecdotes, and I’m nowhere near 7 EG so you are the expert on that. There is some conflicting info with some guys saying 6 EG is the 50/50 point and now others saying 7 EG is the 50/50 point.

From everything I’ve read I would put the 50/50 at 6.5 EG like I originally showed. Which would make about 6.25 EG the ideal girth for the greatest number of women.

Maybe “too big” in terms of girth is not a standard normal distribution either. Maybe it’s skewed just like dick size.

Or maybe the hidden variables, like technique and partner pre-selection for size, are the reason some guys have problems at 6 but other guys don’t at 7.

7EG is a bit too much in my opinion. I was a tad under 6.5EG before I started and I got most of my girth gains before I knew 6.5EG was considered large. I’m a tall guy so anyone who’s tall knows we always seem smaller than we really are downstairs. I would always look down there and think I could or should be bigger. Point being I’d be happy with a 6.5EG or maybe back at what I started. 7EG is nice and like I said some of the women I’ve been with love it, but it seems more dislike it on average

I’m here for the length and that’s what I’ve been going for

I don’t agree that 7 inch is too much girth. Not 7, or 7 and a half or even 8 inches of erect mid shaft girth. And ten inches base girth is not even close to too much. If you understand how to handle yourself, no matter what the size of your dick, you can make a woman as happy as you want in bed, and give her the maximum pleasure she can achieve. One thing I have noticed, though, is a huge cock generally turns a woman on.

What? That is a ridiculous thing to say. Eight inches girth? Oooof. I have no words.

All of this is simply laughable. Man I needed to read a good joke! Thanks!!

I’m pretty sure a 10 inch girth would be like the middle part of a traffic cone haha

Haha!

So what would be like best overall size? I know theres tonnes upon tonnes of factors (one of them being your partners own capabilities to deal with the size), but what would you wager is the best?

Lets say the requirements have to be:
Most pleasure for the girl
Most likely to fit without much or any tearing
The “shock” factor (so when she first realises your size, you want to turn them on and have them say “holy shit.” but without making them run half way down the street just to get away from your traffic cone dick aha)

Or something like that

I’ve had experiences with an old girlfriend where I would barely fit, and I’m only like 7.0” BPEL and a little under 5.0 in EG. I’ve had other girls say I’m bigger than most people they have been with, but I wouldn’t really consider myself that big. Bigger than average? Sure, but not huge or anything like that

I’m not an expert, or as “knowledged filled” as any of you guys, not by a long shot! But my thoughts are something like somewhere between 7.5-8.0 BPEL and 5.0-5.5 in EG?